A Bloody Good Time: The Best Bloody Marys in Ottumwa

Published March 3, 2025

Looking for the perfect Bloody Mary to kick off your weekend or spice up your brunch plans? Well, you're in luck! Our panel of Bloody Mary aficionados hit the town, visiting a variety of spots, and armed with a meticulous list of criteria, they’ve sipped and savored their way through some of the best cocktails in town. From the boldest blends of spice to the most creative garnishes, we’ve narrowed it down to the ultimate picks that’ll make your taste buds cheer. Ready to discover where to find the best Bloody Mary in town? Let’s dive in!

Flavor

When it comes to the Bloody Mary experience, flavor reigns supreme. Our experts were looking for that perfect balance of spice, tang, and umami and the competition was tight. Ultimately though, Wissota Chophouse emerged on top, thanks to their perfectly balanced flavor profile. They crafted a Bloody Mary that hit all the right notes—spicy yet smooth, with just enough complexity to make it memorable without overwhelming the palate. This local favorite stood out for its attention to detail and expertly crafted blend, making it a clear winner in a category where flavor is everything.

Spice

If you're like us, the spicier the Bloody Mary, the better. And on our tour, one stop really took it up a notch — the historic Tom-Tom Tap. The Tom-Tom knows exactly how to balance flavor with that perfect kick of spice. We’re talking about a drink that hits you right at the back of the throat and lingers just long enough to make you want another sip. You know it's good when one of our judges, who usually avoids spice, is coughing after every drink.

Garnishes

Garnishes are what elevate a Bloody Mary from a simple cocktail to an unforgettable experience. While the drink itself packs a punch, it’s the imaginative garnishes that truly steal the show, and each stop on the tour showcased their creativity. However, there was one garnish game-changer that stood out above the rest. For locals, it comes as no surprise that Morgan's Corner claimed the top spot.

Presentation

For this tour, our judges stopped at Warehouse Barbecue, Godfrey's Ale House, Morgan's Corner, Tom-Tom Tap, Wissota Chophouse, and Garrison Rock. Looking to plan your own bloody mary tour? We would also suggest Benchwarmers, Bubba-Q's, and